01 / Keep five financial facts separate
A dollar can appear in five different accounting stories. They are not interchangeable.
| Bucket | Meaning | What would prove it |
|---|---|---|
| Authority / contract ceiling | Maximum or authorized amount that may be spent. | Executed contract, amendment, appropriation or encumbrance. |
| Invoice | Amount a vendor requested for identified work. | Invoice and supporting itemization. |
| Actual payment | Money actually disbursed, net of credits/refunds. | Payment ledger, voucher or controller data. |
| Avoidable-work / capacity value | A model pricing staff time that might be redirected if audited rework is reduced. | Measured hours × defensible role-specific value assumptions. |
| Cash saving | An actual payment avoided or lawful budget reduction. | Before/after expenditure evidence or cancelled/avoided obligation. |
02 / A $600,000 amendment is not a $600,000 waste finding
Use the procurement document for what it actually proves.
The 2024 Procurement Justification Form identifies a $600,000 Tyler amendment request. It describes up to $525,000 for additional professional services/custom development and up to $75,000 for a Technical Account Manager. It also says custom development must be approved in an Authorization Order before work is performed and expressly states that the arrangement is not a guarantee that the funds will be used.
The public-interest question is therefore not “Was $600,000 wasted?” The testable questions are: Which work was authorized? What was invoiced? What was accepted? What was paid? What operational problem was the work intended to fix? Did the measurable outcome improve?
03 / Family-borne costs belong in the analysis too
Shifting work to a parent is not the same thing as eliminating cost.
When a filing must be corrected repeatedly, a party may lose work time, pay another fee, travel to a courthouse, print another packet, obtain another professional review, or wait longer for a decision. Those private burdens should be measured separately from public payroll. They should not be silently added to government spending, and reduced public touches should not be called a success if they merely transfer more uncompensated work to families.
Sources and limits
Inspect the record before drawing the conclusion.
- Maine Procurement Services — Service Contract Search — Official portal for current and archived service contracts, including Judicial Branch service contracts.
- Tyler Technologies Procurement Justification Form — NOI 0320240229 — $600,000 amendment request; $525,000 cap for additional professional services; $75,000 TAM cap; stated hourly ceiling of $210 for custom development; expressly not a guarantee of funds.
- Maine Judicial Branch — 2022 State of the Judiciary — States that BerryDunn was hired to assess Maine eCourts after implementation problems caused a pause.
- Maine Judicial Branch — 2024 State of the Judiciary — States that the Branch paused, obtained an independent assessment, reorganized, and later resumed rollout.
- Maine Judicial Branch — Maine eCourts — Current public rollout information and listed features of eCourts/eFileMaine.
- Maine Judicial Branch — eCourts access — Current public explanation of electronic-record access and limitations.
- Administrative Order JB-20-03 (A. 11-26) — Current implementation order governing MRECS during the continuing statewide rollout.
- JTforME fiscal accountability briefing — Public briefing with stated assumptions, workload model, fiscal sensitivity analysis and explicit limitations.
- JTforME public records tracker — Tracks selected DAFS and Judicial Branch requests and distinguishes acknowledgement, denial and unverified production status.
This is public-interest analysis, not an audit finding, legal opinion, procurement determination, or individualized legal advice. Contract ceilings are not the same as amounts paid. An observed problem is not automatically attributable to a vendor. A modeled capacity value is not cash recovered by the State.