01 / What the record says
The project should be evaluated against its own stated purposes.
| Record | What it establishes | What it does not establish |
|---|---|---|
| 2022 State of the Judiciary | The Branch reported pilot problems, paused the next phase, and hired BerryDunn to conduct an assessment. | It does not identify every defect, assign legal responsibility, or establish the cost of each problem. |
| 2024 State of the Judiciary | The Branch reported that the pause, independent assessment and reorganization preceded renewed implementation. | It is not an independent acceptance audit of every Tyler deliverable. |
| 2024 Tyler PJF / CT 202207120*0098 | $600,000 amendment request; custom development capped at $525,000; TAM capped at $75,000; custom-development rate not to exceed $210/hour; document says this is not a guarantee of funds. | The ceiling is not proof that the full amount was invoiced or paid. |
| 2026 eCourts rollout pages | York moved to eFiling March 30, 2026; other regions followed on different schedules. | Rollout itself does not prove user outcomes, acceptance quality or cost effectiveness. |
02 / The missing contract-performance chain
Do not stop at the procurement document.
- Agreement: What exact service, support, upgrade or deliverable was authorized?
- Authorization order: For custom development, what specific work was approved before work began?
- Invoice: What was billed, at what rate, for what deliverable or period?
- Acceptance: Who documented that the work met the applicable acceptance standard?
- Payment: What amount was actually disbursed, credited, refunded or adjusted?
- Performance: What measurable user-facing outcome changed?
- Remediation: If performance failed, what defect ticket, cure, credit, holdback or new deliverable followed?
The current JTforME records tracker shows that contract/payment requests were acknowledged by DAFS while the separate Judicial Branch administrative-record request for BerryDunn oversight/acceptance records was denied under JB-05-20 IV.B. R48 therefore marks acceptance and invoice evidence as incomplete rather than assuming an answer.
03 / Public contract register
Known public records and unresolved proof.
| Item | Status | Next proof needed |
|---|---|---|
| Tyler additional-support amendment, 2024 | Official PJF located | Executed amendment, authorization orders, invoices, payment ledger and acceptance records. |
| BerryDunn assessment engagement | Engagement confirmed publicly | Executed scope, assessment/deliverables, amendments, invoices and acceptance records. |
| DAFS procurement/payment FOAA | Acknowledged | Rolling production, time/cost estimate, produced records or a documented withholding determination. |
| Judicial Branch BerryDunn administrative-record request | Denied under JB-05-20 IV.B | Any available review/reconsideration route and records obtainable through other custodians. |
Sources and limits
Inspect the record before drawing the conclusion.
- Maine Procurement Services — Service Contract Search — Official portal for current and archived service contracts, including Judicial Branch service contracts.
- Tyler Technologies Procurement Justification Form — NOI 0320240229 — $600,000 amendment request; $525,000 cap for additional professional services; $75,000 TAM cap; stated hourly ceiling of $210 for custom development; expressly not a guarantee of funds.
- Maine Judicial Branch — 2022 State of the Judiciary — States that BerryDunn was hired to assess Maine eCourts after implementation problems caused a pause.
- Maine Judicial Branch — 2024 State of the Judiciary — States that the Branch paused, obtained an independent assessment, reorganized, and later resumed rollout.
- Maine Judicial Branch — Maine eCourts — Current public rollout information and listed features of eCourts/eFileMaine.
- Maine Judicial Branch — eCourts access — Current public explanation of electronic-record access and limitations.
- Administrative Order JB-20-03 (A. 11-26) — Current implementation order governing MRECS during the continuing statewide rollout.
- JTforME fiscal accountability briefing — Public briefing with stated assumptions, workload model, fiscal sensitivity analysis and explicit limitations.
- JTforME public records tracker — Tracks selected DAFS and Judicial Branch requests and distinguishes acknowledgement, denial and unverified production status.
This is public-interest analysis, not an audit finding, legal opinion, procurement determination, or individualized legal advice. Contract ceilings are not the same as amounts paid. An observed problem is not automatically attributable to a vendor. A modeled capacity value is not cash recovered by the State.