PUBLICATION COPY · VERBATIM TEXT OF THE EMAIL AS SENT
Are you people fucking high?
PUBLIC NOTICE TO THE SEVEN DISHONORABLE INJUSTICES OF MAINE’S SUPREME JUDICIAL COURT
AND FORMAL CONSTITUTIONAL PETITION TO MAINE’S EXECUTIVE AND LEGISLATIVE BRANCHES FOR INVESTIGATION, IMPEACHMENT, AND REMOVAL
November 12, 2026
TO THE DISHONORABLE INJUSTICES:
- Dishonorable Chief Injustice Valerie Stanfill
- Dishonorable Associate Injustice Andrew Mead
- Dishonorable Associate Injustice Catherine Connors
- Dishonorable Associate Injustice Rick Lawrence
- Dishonorable Associate Injustice Wayne Douglas
- Dishonorable Associate Injustice Julia Lipez
- Dishonorable Associate Injustice Christopher Taub
AND TO THE OFFICIALS ENTRUSTED WITH CONSTITUTIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY:
- Governor-elect Hannah M. Pingree
- Senate President Matthea Daughtry
- Speaker of the House Ryan Fecteau
- Senate Majority Leader Teresa Pierce
- House Majority Leader Matthew Moonen
- Senate Republican Leader Trey Stewart
- Incoming House Republican Leader Kenneth Fredette
- All incoming and returning members of Maine’s 133rd Legislature
RE: SIXTEEN FUCKING YEARS OF FORESEEABLE HARM, PROCEDURAL ABSURDITY, JUDICIAL DEFERENCE, AND A FORMAL PETITION FOR CONSTITUTIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY
To the seven Dishonorable Injustices:
What the actual fuck is wrong with the institution you people are running?
For more than sixteen fucking years, I have told nearly every professional involved in my family’s affairs precisely what I believed Amanda Morse and her attorney, Patrick S. Bedard, were trying to accomplish, how their conduct was undermining my relationship with my son, and exactly what foreseeable harms would result if the courts continued allowing the underlying issues to go unexamined and uncorrected.
SIXTEEN. FUCKING. YEARS.
I did not discover these problems yesterday.
I did not manufacture these concerns after losing a hearing.
I did not suddenly invent sixteen years of court orders, guardians ad litem, contempt proceedings, medical-record disputes, financial-disclosure disputes, school records, therapeutic interventions, and documented communications.
I came to your fucking profession for help.
Again.
And again.
And again.
I warned that my son was being placed in the middle of adult conflict. I warned of parental interference. I documented recurring problems involving medical information, school attendance, financial obligations, therapeutic access, and the progressive deterioration of a father-son relationship.
I asked for independent investigations. I asked for neutral professionals. I asked for enforcement of existing orders. I asked for meaningful intervention before the consequences became irreversible.
And your institution’s response, in my experience, has amounted to an endless procession of expensive paperwork, self-important procedural posturing, and excuses for why someone else should address the actual fucking problem.
How many times must a parent identify a foreseeable harm before a supposedly learned profession becomes responsible for examining it?
At what point does judicial ignorance stop being a convenient excuse and become an institutional failure worthy of removal proceedings?
And precisely how much of a child’s fucking childhood must be sacrificed before the preservation of professional comfort becomes unacceptable?
I. YOUR NOVEMBER 10 DECISION IS A MASTERCLASS IN PROCEDURAL ABSURDITY
Let’s examine the latest masterpiece of institutional self-preservation.
Pat Doe v. Justin A. Tahai, 2026 ME 106. November 10, 2026.
The panel consisted of Justices Mead, Connors, Douglas, and Lipez, together with Active Retired Justice Humphrey.
Your Court acknowledged that the trial court appeared to have made a factual mistake concerning the chronology of the Thanksgiving 2024 events. But apparently that mistake was not significant enough to warrant correction of the judgment.
Then, in the same fucking opinion, your Court repeatedly invoked the absence of a hearing transcript to presume that the evidence supported the trial court’s findings.
ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME?
I had documented my inability to afford the $1,515.90 transcript deposit. I pursued transcript relief. I requested access to the electronic recording. I pursued alternatives for completing the appellate record.
Your judicial machinery nevertheless proceeded without the transcript. Then your Court invoked the absence of the transcript as a reason to presume that the challenged findings were correct.
I understand the appellate rule you applied.
That is precisely the fucking problem.
You have constructed an institution in which the procedural mechanics can produce an outcome that is formally defensible while leaving the underlying access-to-justice problem unresolved.
A trial court makes a factual mistake? Harmless.
A self-represented parent cannot afford the evidentiary transcript? Presume the trial court was correct.
A parent raises longstanding substantive concerns about child welfare and implementation? Explain the standards of review, affirm the judgment, and move along.
What a brilliantly convenient little arrangement.
Your profession calls this deference. I call the resulting institutional experience a grotesque failure to distinguish the administration of procedure from the administration of justice.
The doctrine may be established. That does not make its consequences fucking acceptable.
And no, I do not accept that the Court meaningfully resolved my central practical objection about how contact provisions are implemented when the other parent treats my son’s preferences as an effective veto after all the years you idiots allowed her lowlife family to continue poisoning him despite repeated notice.
Formal decision-making authority and practical obstruction are not the same question.
A competent institution should be capable of recognizing the distinction.
UMaine Law was clearly a different place back in the 80's.....
Now I am not saying that Patrick S. Bedard shoved a paddle up John B. Lucy's ass during hazing nor am I saying that he fell in love at that time; however, there are some reasonable concerns regarding their having been colleagues for decades.
II. YOUR PROCEDURAL BULLSHIT HAS BECOME THE HARM
I have spent an extraordinary amount of time documenting, organizing, indexing, serving, correcting, resubmitting, and preserving evidence that should have received competent consideration long ago.
Meanwhile, Maine’s electronic filing machinery has added its own breathtaking layers of operational idiocy.
Wrong filing code. Missing proposed order. Wrong form. Separate PDF required. Authorized service contact not provided. Resubmit within four business days. Include the precise relation-back language.
And, in recent rejection notices, apparently we cannot even consistently identify whether the governing relation-back instruction is under Rule 35(E) or 35(F).
WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU DOING?
This is a court system, not a goddamn scavenger hunt through a vendor’s malfunctioning user interface.
I spent years as an information technology engineer. When a system repeatedly fails to process legitimate work reliably, the answer is not to lecture its users about respecting the system. The answer is to identify the defects, correct the workflow, and hold the people responsible for the system accountable.
Yet your institution appears extraordinarily comfortable transferring the consequences of its operational shortcomings onto the very people it supposedly exists to serve.
You get a procedural defect. I get another rejection.
You get another administrative explanation. I get another day consumed by paperwork.
You get another opportunity to invoke established procedure.
My son gets older.
And apparently I am supposed to bow my head, say “Your Honor,” and express gratitude for this spectacular display of bureaucratic dysfunction.
Fuck you.
Your procedural and operational idiocy should have been shipped back across the pond 250 years ago. You are hereby invited to return it now.
You are public servants. You are not royalty. Your procedures are not sacred. Your authority is not a substitute for competence.
And the continued preservation of asinine operational practices does not become honorable merely because judges and lawyers have grown accustomed to them.
III. STOP PRETENDING THAT THE PASSAGE OF TIME IS HARMLESS
My son was born in 2010. The original family proceedings began that same year.
The present period of severe disruption dates to Thanksgiving 2024.
The consolidated hearing occurred January 16, 2026. The operative order followed February 11.
It is now November 12, 2026. Almost two years have passed since the late-2024 events began unfolding, and more than nine months have passed since the February order.
Through this entire period, I have continued documenting concerns about meaningful implementation, contact, counseling, and parental cooperation.
A childhood cannot be stayed pending appeal. A birthday cannot be remanded. A holiday cannot be reconstructed through an amended judgment. A father’s absence from ordinary daily life cannot be corrected retroactively by a court finally deciding that somebody should have done something differently.
YOU CANNOT FUCKING GIVE THOSE YEARS BACK.
And I am done accepting professional explanations that treat that reality as secondary to procedural convenience.
I have argued for years that Ms. Morse and Attorney Bedard’s conduct deserves far more rigorous examination than it has received. I contend that their actions and litigation positions have contributed to prolonged and foreseeable damage to the father-son relationship.
Those are allegations for fair, evidence-based examination—not findings I am asking anyone to manufacture.
But when the same concerns recur across more than a decade, the answer is not to dismiss the entire history because the person reporting it is understandably furious.
The answer is to investigate the fucking evidence. Your ridiculous antiquated game of bullshit is not substantive investigation.
And when a court cannot distinguish anger about alleged harm from proof that the underlying allegations are false, that court has a serious analytical problem.
My tone does not excuse another person’s misconduct. My profanity does not establish that my concerns are unfounded. My refusal to flatter the judiciary does not relieve it of its responsibilities.
And the fact that your profession dislikes being publicly criticized does not make criticism a substitute for the substantive questions I have repeatedly presented.
IV. YOU DO NOT GET TO KEEP YOUR TITLES FREE FROM CONSTITUTIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY
The Maine Constitution begins with the people. Not the judiciary. Not the Bar. Not the Supreme Judicial Court.
THE PEOPLE.
Article I, Section 2 expressly recognizes the people’s authority to alter and reform government.
And the Maine Constitution provides mechanisms for removing judicial officers.
Under Article IV, Part First, Section 8, the House of Representatives has the sole power of impeachment.
Under Article IV, Part Second, Section 7, the Senate has the sole power to try impeachments, with conviction requiring a two-thirds vote of the members present.
Under Article IX, Section 5, civil officers may be removed for misdemeanor in office through impeachment, and the Governor may remove an officer following an address of both branches of the Legislature, subject to the constitutional requirements of stated causes, notice, and an opportunity for a hearing.
In other words:
THE CONSTITUTION PROVIDES A MECHANISM TO REMOVE YOU FROM OFFICE.
Your titles are not hereditary privileges. Your judicial commissions are not personal property. And your authority remains subject to the constitutional structure that created it.
I recognize that disagreement with an appellate ruling is not, by itself, proof of impeachable misconduct.
That is why I am demanding an independent inquiry into the conduct, administration, decision-making processes, documented notices, access barriers, and consequences—not an invented finding of guilt.
But the constitutional mechanisms exist for a reason. And I see absolutely no fucking reason why public officials entrusted with the highest judicial authority in Maine should be exempt from a serious, independent examination of whether their performance and conduct warrant those mechanisms being invoked.
V. FORMAL PETITION TO THE LEGISLATURE AND GOVERNOR-ELECT PINGREE
Governor-elect Pingree, Senate President Daughtry, Speaker Fecteau, and the incoming legislative leadership:
I now formally petition the executive and legislative branches to exercise their independent constitutional oversight responsibilities.
I ask the House of Representatives to initiate a documented, impartial investigation into whether the conduct of any member of the Maine Supreme Judicial Court provides grounds for impeachment.
I ask the Senate to prepare to discharge its constitutional responsibilities should articles of impeachment be adopted.
I ask both chambers to examine whether the alternative removal-by-address procedure under Article IX, Section 5 is warranted by evidence concerning any individual judicial officer.
And I ask Governor-elect Pingree, upon assuming office, to give any constitutionally proper legislative address for removal the independent and serious consideration it deserves.
This investigation should examine, among other things:
- Whether persistent administrative and procedural failures have been knowingly tolerated despite documented access-to-justice concerns.
- Whether transcript-access practices and financial barriers have produced unjustifiable obstacles to meaningful appellate review.
- Whether the judiciary’s internal processes provide adequate protection against prolonged, foreseeable harms to children during family-law proceedings.
- Whether electronic filing rejections, administrative non-presentment practices, and repeated correction cycles represent systemic failures requiring legislative intervention.
- Whether identifiable conduct by individual judicial officers—not mere disagreement with judicial outcomes—provides a legally sufficient basis for discipline, impeachment, or removal.
I ask for an actual inquiry grounded in original records, not another bureaucratic performance in which a government body announces that somebody else’s office should handle the problem.
Preserve the records. Examine the orders. Review the electronic filing logs. Review the underlying transcript requests and denials. Review the procedural objections, the docket history, and the documented attempts to seek relief.
Distinguish the justices who participated in particular decisions from those whose responsibility concerns judicial administration. Provide notice and due process to any officer accused of misconduct. Then make findings.
DO YOUR FUCKING JOBS.
No judicial officer should be removed merely because a citizen is angry with a decision. But no judicial officer should escape constitutionally authorized scrutiny merely because colleagues are uncomfortable examining one another.
I am not demanding a predetermined verdict.
I AM DEMANDING THAT THE PEOPLE ENTRUSTED WITH THE AUTHORITY TO INVESTIGATE ACTUALLY INVESTIGATE.
VI. REVOLUTIONS HAVE BEEN STARTED FOR FAR LESS
Revolutions have been started for far less.
And Maine’s own Constitution recognizes that governmental authority originates with the people, not with the people fortunate enough to occupy its highest offices.
My efforts are directed toward lawful, peaceful, constitutional reform, public accountability, and the exercise of the people’s rights to petition, criticize, organize, and demand responsible government.
I am not threatening violence. I am challenging your complacency with public records, lawful criticism, independent scrutiny, and the constitutional powers of the other branches of government.
You do not own justice.
You do not own the Constitution. You do not own the public’s respect.
And you sure as fuck do not possess a divine entitlement to retain positions of public trust without accountability.
Your profession lectures ordinary citizens about consequences, obligations, standards, procedures, and responsibility.
Fine. Apply those fucking principles to yourselves.
If the evidence establishes professional failure or misconduct, there must be meaningful accountability.
If it establishes grounds for removal, use the constitutional machinery established for that purpose.
If it identifies defects in the administration of justice, correct them instead of continuing to sacrifice families to institutional inertia.
VII. TO THE SEVEN DISHONORABLE INJUSTICES: THIS IS NOTICE, NOT ANOTHER REQUEST FOR YOUR PERMISSION
I am not asking the Law Court for another fucking order. I am not requesting reconsideration. I am not filing another procedural application begging the same institution to acknowledge the consequences of its own practices.
This is notice of my public condemnation of your institutional performance.
The petition for investigation and potential removal is addressed to the branches constitutionally entrusted with that authority.
I have spent sixteen years attempting to obtain meaningful protection of my son’s interests and our relationship through the system established for that purpose.
I have watched time disappear while professionals debate procedure, responsibility, and the supposed inadequacy of my manners.
I have watched repeated substantive concerns become entangled in an endless argument about whether I expressed them politely enough for the comfort of the people paid to address them.
I AM FUCKING DONE PLAYING THAT GAME.
I will not pretend that professional credentials establish moral authority. I will not pretend that judicial status confers infallibility. I will not pretend that a legally final decision necessarily resolves the underlying real-world problems.
And I will not excuse foreseeable harm merely because its consequences can be buried beneath the phrase “harmless error.”
You want respect? Earn it.
You want public confidence? Demonstrate competence, accountability, and a willingness to correct institutional failures.
You want your titles? Then be prepared to demonstrate why you deserve to continue holding the offices behind them.
THE PEOPLE HAVE A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO QUESTION THAT. THE OTHER TWO BRANCHES HAVE CONSTITUTIONAL MECHANISMS TO ACT.
I am petitioning them to examine whether those mechanisms are warranted.
You were entrusted with the administration of justice, not the preservation of an antiquated procedural protection racket.
I asked your profession to help protect my son. I warned of the foreseeable consequences. I provided the documentation. I pursued the available procedures.
And my family has continued bearing the consequences of this prolonged institutional failure.
ENOUGH OF THE FUCKING EXCUSES.
No more professional comfort at the expense of children. No more procedural absurdity masquerading as competence. No more deference without accountability. No more treating the passage of childhood as a harmless administrative detail.
STOP HARMING KIDS.
ESPECIALLY MINE.
Justin A. Tahai
Father • Engineer • Author
Self-represented litigant and Maine citizen
PUBLIC NOTICE TO THE JUDICIARY. FORMAL PETITION FOR LEGISLATIVE AND EXECUTIVE ACCOUNTABILITY.
Judicial notice only; no judicial ruling or reconsideration requested — I am not waiting another fucking year. The requested investigation and consideration of constitutional removal procedures are directed to Maine’s legislative and executive branches.
#StopHarmingOurKids
Primary public authorities:
Maine Constitution:
https://legislature.maine.gov/ros/LawsOfMaine/App/views/constitution.html
Pat Doe v. Justin A. Tahai, 2026 ME 106:
https://www.courts.maine.gov/courts/sjc/lawcourt/2026/26me106.pdf