Skip to content
JTforMEFAMILIES · PUBLIC SERVICE · ACCOUNTABILITY
Menu

DISCUSSION DRAFT / LEGISLATIVE MECHANISM / SAFEGUARDS

A reform proposal should
survive the implementation meeting.

Model language that names the work, owner, data, safeguards, funding conditions, family-facing outcome, and decision rule.

This is discussion language for legislative counsel—not enacted law.

The Revisor of Statutes and nonpartisan legislative staff perform official bill-drafting functions for legislators. Fiscal notes are prepared through the Legislature’s official fiscal process. The language below is a public specification intended to make the requested mechanism, safeguards, data and review obligations concrete.

Do not cite this page as current law. It is proposed language. A sponsor, committee, Revisor, legislative counsel, fiscal staff, affected agencies and constitutional review may materially change it.

Family Court Process Cost and Rework Report

Discussion draft

Sec. 1. Family Court Process Cost and Rework Report. 1. Definitions. For purposes of this section: A. “Logical filing” means one document or set of documents submitted to accomplish one procedural act, including corrected resubmissions associated with the same act. B. “Human review” means a documented review by court, administrative, vendor, or contracted personnel. C. “Rework event” means an additional review, correction, resubmission, scheduling action, or implementation action beyond the first appropriate processing event. D. “Avoidable rework” means a rework event that an independent review determines could reasonably have been prevented without removing a necessary safeguard. 2. Baseline. The Judicial Branch shall publish a 90-day baseline, by case type and region where disclosure is lawful and statistically reliable, including first-pass acceptance, return reasons, human reviews per logical filing, time to substantive action, and time from order to documented implementation where measurable. 3. Independent review. A stratified sample of returned, accepted, abandoned, and pending matters must be independently coded. The review must distinguish necessary safeguards, filer defects, system or vendor defects, inconsistent instructions, third-party barriers, and indeterminate or mixed causes. 4. Privacy. No report may identify a child, party, confidential proceeding, protected health information, education record, or sealed matter. Small-cell suppression and aggregation must be used where necessary. 5. Report. The report must state methods, limitations, missing data, cost assumptions, corrective actions, responsible owners, milestone dates, and the evidence used to determine whether a correction worked.

Condition new process-improvement funding on deliverables.

Discussion draft

Sec. 2. Milestone-based process-improvement funding. 1. Scope. This section applies only to new discretionary appropriations or allocations specifically designated for family-process modernization, eFiling improvement, data integration, contracted project oversight, or comparable process-improvement work. 2. Protected functions. Emergency relief, constitutionally required adjudication, essential staffing, accessibility, cybersecurity, and services necessary to protect a child or victim may not be suspended solely because a project milestone is disputed. 3. Release conditions. Applicable incremental funds may be released only after publication or confidential legislative receipt, as appropriate, of: A. the baseline and acceptance criteria; B. the deliverable owner and deadline; C. exportable event and payment data sufficient for independent evaluation; D. documented acceptance, conditional acceptance, rejection, remediation, credit, or waiver decisions; and E. a corrective plan for unmet milestones. 4. No activity-only metric. Filing counts, ticket closures, training attendance, or administrative dispositions may not be reported as proof of successful outcomes without an identified relationship to family-facing performance.

Review whether a child-impact order can actually be implemented.

Discussion draft

Sec. 3. Child-impact implementation review pilot. 1. Eligibility. The pilot may include orders requiring a provider, supervised contact, relationship-support service, information exchange, transportation arrangement, school or medical coordination, or another implementation step whose failure could materially affect a child. 2. Review. Within the period established by rule or pilot protocol, an authorized reviewer shall determine whether: A. responsibilities are assigned; B. the named service or provider is available; C. scheduling, transportation, payment, consent, information exchange, and protective conditions are workable; D. the ordered or authorized action occurred; and E. a lawful corrective route is identified if it did not occur. 3. Safeguards. The review may not override a protection order, alter custody, compel unsafe contact, disclose confidential treatment information beyond lawful need, or transfer adjudicative authority to a provider or administrator. 4. Measurement. The pilot must measure time to implementation, repeat proceedings, service availability, private cost, adverse events, participant access, and whether lawful obligations were completed.

Publish outcomes without publishing families.

Discussion draft

Sec. 4. Public performance dashboard. The responsible office shall publish aggregate, privacy-protected measures sufficient to evaluate access, timeliness, correction, and implementation. The dashboard must include definitions, data coverage, missing-data notes, revision history, and a warning against treating pending work as automatically overdue or a reduced filing count as automatic evidence of improved access.

Evaluation and sunset

Sec. 5. Independent evaluation; continuation standard. A pilot or funded intervention continues only if the evidence shows improved or maintained safety, meaningful access, and credible operational value without shifting an unmeasured burden onto families. The evaluator shall report adverse effects, unresolved uncertainty, implementation fidelity, and whether the intervention should continue, change, narrow, or end.

Strong model language exposes the hard questions instead of hiding them.

  • Which office may lawfully collect the data?
  • Which measures require rulemaking, legislation, appropriation, administrative order, or a pilot agreement?
  • How are confidential family matters aggregated?
  • What is the fiscal impact and who prepares the official fiscal note?
  • How is judicial independence protected while administrative performance remains measurable?
  • What result ends or narrows the intervention?