Skip to content
JTforMEFAMILIES · PUBLIC SERVICE · ACCOUNTABILITY
Menu

EVIDENCE LIBRARY / SELECTED STUDIES

Read the result.
Keep the limit attached.

A selected evidence library for family stability, prevention, resources and usable justice.

Filter the evidence. Keep the limitation attached.

This selected library is not a systematic review and does not claim to capture every relevant publication. Related papers from the same program are not counted as independent replications. Each entry states the narrow public use JTforME draws from the source and the conclusion that remains unsupported.

Twenty-five selected studies and analyses.

Conflict & emotional security

Interparental Conflict in Kindergarten and Adolescent Adjustment

Cummings, George, McCoy & Davies · 2012 · Source

Limited causal inference
Prospective longitudinal235 families followed from kindergarten into adolescenceR49-01
Reported result
Earlier interparental conflict was associated with later adolescent adjustment through children’s emotional insecurity in the authors’ longitudinal model.
Responsible use
Monitoring the emotional conditions children experience during prolonged adult conflict and designing supports that reduce exposure and insecurity.
Does not establish
Not a study of court delay, custody allocation, or any individual family. Longitudinal mediation does not prove that one parent caused a particular child’s symptoms.
Conflict & emotional security

Family-Level Antecedents of Children’s Patterns of Reactivity to Interparental Conflict

Davies, Pearson, Cao & Sturge-Apple · 2023 · Source

Limited causal inference
Longitudinal, multi-method243 preschool children and their parents; racially diverse U.S. sampleR49-02
Reported result
The study examined how family-level conditions were associated with distinct patterns of children’s reactions to interparental conflict.
Responsible use
Assessing the form, context and child response to conflict rather than counting conflict as one undifferentiated exposure.
Does not establish
The sample and developmental stage limit generalization. The study does not determine responsibility in a legal dispute.
Conflict & emotional security

Interparental Conflict, Children’s Reactivity and School Adjustment

Davies, Thompson, Hentges, Parry & Sturge-Apple · 2022 · Source

Limited causal inference
Three-wave longitudinal243 preschool children and parents followed annuallyR49-03
Reported result
Conflict predicted changes in children’s emotional reactivity and behavioral dysregulation; emotional reactivity predicted later school problems in the reported model.
Responsible use
Treating school functioning and emotional reactivity as outcomes worth monitoring when conflict is sustained.
Does not establish
The results do not establish that a specific absence, tardy, court event or parenting arrangement caused school problems.
Conflict & emotional security

Interparental Conflict and Adolescent Emotional Security Across Family Structures

O’Hara, Cummings & Davies · 2024 · Source

Limited causal inference
Observational across family structuresAdolescents in married and divorced/separated family structuresR49-04
Reported result
The study examined how conflict related to different forms of emotional security and mental-health problems across family structures.
Responsible use
Avoiding the assumption that family structure alone explains risk; conflict and security processes require direct attention.
Does not establish
Observational associations do not establish what a court should order in an individual case.
Conflict & emotional security

Lessons Learned from Witnessing Constructive Interparental Conflict

Davies and colleagues · 2025 · Source

Limited causal inference
Three-wave longitudinal238 preschool children and mothers followed through first gradeR49-05
Reported result
Constructive conflict predicted later gains in children’s emotion-situation knowledge and social problem solving in the reported longitudinal model.
Responsible use
Distinguishing destructive conflict from disagreement handled with resolution, respect and usable problem solving.
Does not establish
Constructive disagreement is not appropriate where coercion, violence or safety risk makes joint engagement unsafe.
Parent–child relationships

Nonresident Fathers’ Contributions to Adolescent Well-Being

King & Sobolewski · 2006 · Source

Limited causal inference
Observational453 adolescents with nonresident fathersR49-06
Reported result
Relationship quality and responsive fathering were modestly associated with fewer behavioral and emotional problems; mother–child relationship quality also mattered.
Responsible use
Examining the substance and supportiveness of both parent–child relationships rather than residential labels alone.
Does not establish
Associations do not establish the effect of a custody schedule, and safety cannot be inferred from contact frequency.
Parent–child relationships

Nonresidential Father Engagement and Long-Term Offspring Outcomes

Modecki, Hagan, Sandler & Wolchik · 2015 · Source

Limited causal inference
Longitudinal profile analysis156 offspring followed from adolescent measures to later outcomesR49-07
Reported result
Profiles combining involvement, support and conflict were associated with different later outcomes.
Responsible use
Considering relationship quality, contact and interparental conflict together rather than treating any one variable as dispositive.
Does not establish
Small, predominantly White sample; profile membership was not randomly assigned; drawn from the New Beginnings research program.
Parent–child relationships

Non-Residential Father Involvement, Conflict and Child Mental Health

Sandler and colleagues · 2016 · Source

Limited causal inference
Longitudinal profile analysis240 children assessed after divorce and followed six yearsR49-08
Reported result
Children in the low-contact, moderate-conflict, low-support profile had more later problems than some other profiles after covariate adjustment.
Responsible use
Investigating withdrawal, support and conflict together; rejecting a simplistic “more contact always solves everything” or “conflict makes a safe relationship irrelevant” rule.
Does not establish
Profile analyses are observational; they do not establish a legal presumption or determine safety in a specific family.
Parent–child relationships

Post-Divorce Conflict, Fear of Abandonment and Children’s Mental Health

O’Hara, Rhodes, Wolchik, Sandler & Tein · 2021 · Source

Limited causal inference
Longitudinal mediation559 children ages 9–18 in a prevention-study sampleR49-09
Reported result
Earlier conflict predicted later fear of abandonment, which predicted subsequent mental-health problems in the reported models; expected buffering by parenting quality was not observed as hypothesized.
Responsible use
Addressing children’s insecurity directly and not assuming a warm parent relationship automatically neutralizes ongoing conflict.
Does not establish
Children were not randomly assigned to conflict; related analyses from one research program are not independent replications.
Parent–child relationships

Parent–Adolescent Relationships and Young Adult Health

Ford, Pool, Kahn, Jaccard & Halpern · 2023 · Source

Limited causal inference
Large observational cohortAdd Health analyses with 10,744 mother-relationship and 8,214 father-relationship observationsR49-10
Reported result
More positive adolescent perceptions of relationships with mothers and fathers were associated with multiple favorable young-adult outcomes.
Responsible use
Treating adolescent relationships with both parents as developmentally relevant rather than assuming parental support stops mattering as independence grows.
Does not establish
Observational design; limited detail on nonresident-parent relationships; unmeasured differences remain possible.
Prevention programs

Six-Year Follow-up of Preventive Interventions for Children of Divorce

Wolchik and colleagues · 2002 · Source

Stronger causal inference for tested programs
Randomized controlled trial, six-year follow-upFamilies assigned to defined preventive programs or comparison conditionR49-11
Reported result
Specified parenting and child-focused preventive programs produced benefits on several measured adolescent outcomes at follow-up.
Responsible use
Testing defined preventive services with measurable objectives rather than assuming that any service bearing a reassuring label works.
Does not establish
Effects cannot be transferred automatically to different providers, populations, doses or programs.
Prevention programs

Program to Promote High-Quality Parenting by Divorced and Separated Fathers

Sandler and colleagues · 2018 · Source

Stronger causal inference for tested program
Randomized evaluation384 divorced or separated fathers in the NBP-Dads trialR49-12
Reported result
The program improved some parenting and child outcomes, with effects varying across outcomes and baseline family characteristics.
Responsible use
Developing and testing the quality of fathering rather than treating fathers as either automatically beneficial or automatically expendable.
Does not establish
The intervention is not evidence for contact regardless of safety and does not validate untested “reunification” practices.
Prevention programs

New Beginnings Program Delivered Through Community Agencies

Sandler and colleagues · 2020 · Source

Stronger causal inference for tested program
Randomized effectiveness trial830 parents recruited through family courts in four countiesR49-13
Reported result
The 10-session program showed moderated benefits in parenting and child mental-health outcomes compared with an active two-session condition. Attendance was incomplete, and effects were not uniform across groups.
Responsible use
Evaluating real-world delivery, reach, attendance and subgroup performance—not just assignment to a service.
Does not establish
Court recruitment and a program name do not make the results applicable to every court-ordered service.
Prevention programs

Developmental Cascade Effects of a Parenting-Focused Program

Wolchik, Tein, Winslow, Minney, Sandler & Masten · 2021 · Source

Stronger causal inference for tested program pathways
15-year follow-up of randomized trialLong-term follow-up of a randomized prevention trial for divorced familiesR49-14
Reported result
The authors examined pathways from intervention-related parenting changes to competence in emerging adulthood.
Responsible use
Looking beyond short-term attendance and measuring whether an intervention changes parenting processes and later functioning.
Does not establish
Long-term follow-up of one program does not establish that all interventions have lasting effects.
Material resources

Poverty and Psychopathology: A Natural Experiment

Costello, Compton, Keeler & Angold · 2003 · Source

Moderate causal inference for income change in studied setting
Natural experiment / longitudinal1,420 rural children followed over eight yearsR49-15
Reported result
An income supplement that moved some families out of poverty was associated with reductions in conduct and oppositional symptoms, not anxiety or depression.
Responsible use
Treating material resources as relevant to children’s functioning and evaluating whether institutional demands deplete the resources supporting stability.
Does not establish
The study does not convert a legal bill into a predicted diagnosis and does not measure family-court expenses.
Material resources

Transition into Poverty and Child and Maternal Mental Health

Wickham and colleagues · 2017 · Source

Limited causal inference
Longitudinal cohort6,063 families in the UK Millennium Cohort StudyR49-16
Reported result
A first transition into poverty was associated with increased odds of child socioemotional problems and maternal psychological distress after adjustment for measured confounders.
Responsible use
Monitoring the effects of sudden financial strain and avoiding reforms that simply shift public administrative costs onto families.
Does not establish
UK cohort; residual confounding is possible; the study does not establish the effect of a specific support order or litigation expense.
Access to justice

Court Accessibility for Low-Income Divorce Seekers

Greiner, Degnan, Jiménez & Pattanayak · 2021 · Source

Stronger causal inference in studied court system
Randomized field experiment311 low-income people seeking divorceR49-17
Reported result
Assignment to pro bono representation substantially increased filing and divorce completion compared with minimal help in the studied system.
Responsible use
Testing whether a process is actually usable by people without counsel and measuring completion—not merely publishing forms.
Does not establish
The study concerned one divorce system; results do not establish the effect of every lawyer or every court-help program.
Access to justice

Court Forms as a Barrier to Accessing Justice

Grieshofer & Gee · 2021 · Source

Descriptive
Corpus and linguistic analysis85 frequently used civil and family court forms in England and WalesR49-18
Reported result
The authors identified complex syntax, breaks in information flow, ambiguity and misalignment between questions and guidance.
Responsible use
Testing forms and instructions with users and treating comprehensibility as part of access.
Does not establish
Different jurisdiction; linguistic analysis does not prove that simplification alone changes case outcomes.
Access to justice

Even Lawyers Do Not Like Legalese

Martínez, Mollica & Gibson · 2023 · Source

Stronger causal inference for text-comprehension task
Controlled experimentsLawyers and lay readers in experimental comprehension and preference studiesR49-19
Reported result
Participants recalled and understood simplified legal content better than equivalent legalese; lawyers also preferred simplified versions.
Responsible use
Plain-language drafting and testing whether professional conventions create unnecessary comprehension burden.
Does not establish
Contract-language experiments do not establish that every legal term or procedural safeguard should be removed.
Procedural experience

Great Expectations? Litigants Before and After Legal Procedures

Study of state-court litigants · 2020 · Source

Limited causal inference
Prospective litigant survey412 litigants at baseline; 335 at follow-upR49-20
Reported result
Shorter case duration and lawyer involvement were associated with higher later satisfaction and fairness evaluations; attendance patterns also mattered.
Responsible use
Measuring duration, participation and user experience instead of assuming that formal availability equals perceived fairness.
Does not establish
Satisfaction is not proof of legal correctness; observational covariates and selection remain.
Procedural experience

Parent Knowledge and Perceived Fairness in Child Welfare

Study of dependency-court parents · 2020 · Source

Descriptive
Cross-sectional interviews201 parents in ongoing dependency cases in California and FloridaR49-21
Reported result
Parents’ system knowledge was low, and procedural and distributive fairness were distinct dimensions of experience.
Responsible use
Providing understandable explanations and separately measuring process fairness and decision outcomes.
Does not establish
Dependency court differs from private family law; attitudes do not establish whether a specific decision was legally correct.
Court-involved children

Anxiety and Depression Among Children in Family Justice Proceedings

National data-linkage study in Wales · 2022 · Source

Limited causal inference
Population data linkageChildren and young people involved in public and private family-law proceedings compared with matched controlsR49-22
Reported result
Court-involved groups showed higher recorded risks of depression and anxiety than comparison groups.
Responsible use
Treating court-involved children as a population that may need support before, during and after proceedings.
Does not establish
The study does not establish that court proceedings caused the mental-health differences; families entering court may already differ substantially.
Safety & power imbalance

Women’s Perceptions of Fairness in the Civil Protection-Order Process

Qualitative protection-order study · 2018 · Source

Descriptive
Qualitative interviews19 women who sought civil protection ordersR49-23
Reported result
Participants described ways consent and mediation processes could reproduce power inequalities and affect perceived fairness.
Responsible use
Screening for coercion and safety before treating agreement or mediation as inherently beneficial.
Does not establish
Small qualitative sample in one jurisdiction; does not establish that mediation is inappropriate in every case.
Safety & power imbalance

IPV Survivors’ Perspectives on Coping with Family Court Processes

Study of IPV-exposed mothers · 2023 · Source

Descriptive
Qualitative survey responses214 IPV-exposed mothers responding about what helped during family courtR49-24
Reported result
Participants emphasized social support, practical tools, being believed, and barriers in non-trauma-informed processes.
Responsible use
Designing safety-aware navigation, social support and practical assistance without requiring survivors to manage the system alone.
Does not establish
One-sided self-reported experiences cannot adjudicate allegations in individual cases and do not represent all parents or survivors.
Court-involved children

Children’s Understanding and Emotional Reactions to Dependency Court

Study of maltreated children in dependency court · 2009 · Source

Descriptive
Child interview studyChildren ages 4–15 interviewed around court attendanceR49-25
Reported result
Understanding improved with age; greater knowledge was associated with less distress about attending court in parts of the analysis.
Responsible use
Providing developmentally appropriate explanations and not making children infer what legal proceedings mean.
Does not establish
Dependency court context; knowledge does not eliminate distress or determine the appropriate level of child participation.

What this library does not claim.

  • It is a selected public-interest library, not a registered systematic review or clinical guideline.
  • Study populations differ by age, jurisdiction, family structure, race, ethnicity, income and referral setting.
  • Randomized evidence supports only the intervention actually tested under the conditions studied.
  • Observational results may remain affected by unmeasured differences and reverse causation.
  • No entry decides whether contact, restriction, treatment, support or custody is appropriate for a particular child.

Download the evidence reading sheet →